Orange Cake with Orange Buttercream

This tender cake is moist and buttery with tangy citrus flavor in every luscious bite.

Table of Contents

• ❤️ Why you'll love it
• 🥫 Storage
• 📖 Variations
• 💭 Things to know
• 👩‍🍳 FAQs
• 📚 Related recipes
• 🍽️ Serve with...
• 📞 The last word
• 📖 Recipe
• 💬 Comments

❤️ Why you'll love it

• Perfect balance between fresh and sweet flavors
• Egg yolks make the cake layers extra moist and rich
• The slightly tangy orange frosting is lick-the-spoon good

This homemade orange cake recipe hits all the marks of a perfect citrus dessert. Plus, the orange buttercream frosting is made with love (and whipping cream) so that it's super creamy and light—as the famous saying goes, it really is the "icing on top of the cake.

🥫 Storage

American-buttercream cakes (like this one) last at room temperature for two to three days, and then two to three days after that in the refrigerator. Though the frosting is made with butter, the large quantity of sugar helps to preserve it from going bad quickly.

In fact, storing a tender cake in the fridge can dry it out faster. There are always exceptions, of course (like if you add a filling that requires refrigeration) so follow recipes carefully!

Put the cake (or leftovers) in an airtight container—like a cake carrier, in Tupperware, or on a serving plate with a cloche. Once the cake is sliced, I like to press a piece of plastic wrap against the inside of the exposed cake to help it retain some of that delicious moistness.

How To Freeze Orange Layer Cake

Layer cakes like this one hold up really well to freezing. Flash freeze either the whole cake (lucky you if you have the freezer room!) or individual slices until you can handle them without messing up the frosting.

Then, wrap the cake or slices in plastic wrap. Cover the plastic wrap with a layer of aluminum foil for extra protection. You can freeze the cake for about three months.

Unwrap the frozen cake before thawing, then let it sit at room temperature until you're ready to eat! Depending on the size, it might take a few hours or more to fully thaw.

📖 Variations

Don't feel like making a layer cake? Don't have 8-inch pans? No worries! You can still use our favorite orange cake recipe with...

• 2 standard cupcake tins (start checking for doneness after 20 minutes)
• 2, 9-inch round cake pans
• 1, 9x13 sheet cake pan
• 2 dozen hollowed-out and dried orange halves (from 12 fresh oranges.) Set the orange halves in a muffin tin, or slice off just a bit of the bottom of the orange peel so they don't roll. Divide batter evenly into each orange, filling about ⅔ of the way, and bake like cupcakes!

In this orange cake recipe, you'll use the heavenly frosting both as the filling inside and on top. However, next time, feel free to add another filling:

• Dark chocolate ganache—chocolate/orange is a decadent combo!
• Vanilla cream cheese frosting
• Orange curd filling
• Pineapple compote—just make sure it's not too watery.
• Blueberry jam
• A crumble made of almonds, oats, and brown sugar

Here are some other substitutions you may find helpful:

• You can use fresh juice or store-bought.
• Make fresh orange juice from blood oranges for a slight grapefruit/berry flavor.
• If you can't find the water enhancer, use a tablespoon of orange extract. Don't use orange juice in the buttercream or it will curdle.
• Lemon zest can be swapped for orange zest if you need it.
• Some people prefer the flavor of almond instead of vanilla extract.
• Garnish the cake with sugared orange slices, a fresh basil leaf, a sprig of rosemary, more zest, or some slivered almonds for an eye-catching presentation.

💭 Things to know

Expert Tip: Good citrus flavor is key to this orange cake recipe, so you want really fresh ones. Give them a quick sniff before buying—if they don't smell orange-y, they won't taste it, either.

• Use room-temperature ingredients unless the recipe says otherwise!
• Cold eggs separate more easily. So, let them come to room temperature after separating, not before.
• Cake flour is used in some of the most popular cake recipes! I don't recommend swapping all-purpose flour in this orange cake.
• Make sure your baking powder is fresh! If it's even nearing expiration, it could have disastrous results on the cake.
• Use either an electric stand mixer or a handheld mixer.
• Let the cakes cool on a wire cooling rack before frosting. Otherwise, you'll have a slippery, slidey, melty mess!
• Sift your powdered sugar before using it to get out the lumps. It really makes the buttercream taste so much more smooth!

Instructions for Removing Cakes Cleanly from the Pans:

1. Spray the pan with cooking spray, or butter and flour it.
2. Line bottoms of the pans with parchment paper circles.
3. Re-spray or butter and flour the top of the parchment paper.

Tips For Decorating:

• You can build and decorate your cake on the final cake plate if you're nervous about moving it after frosting.
• For a rustic, old-fashioned look, spread the buttercream onto the cake with an icing spatula. We like a nice, thick, swirled layer that makes you want to stick your finger right in the frosting!
• Or, use a turntable and a cake board if you're more experienced.
• Nowadays, it's popular to create pristine, smooth cakes. To achieve this Instagram-worthy look:
  1. First, add a crumb coat, or a thin layer of frosting on the top and sides of the cake. Smooth it as best as you can with an offset spatula or cake scraper. It's okay if you see the cake through this layer. Its purpose is to "lock in" the crumbs for the final coat.
  2. Chill the cake in the fridge until you can gently touch the crumb coat without denting it.
  3. Apply another layer of frosting to the top and sides of the cake.
  4. Smooth out the top and sides as best as you can, using a light touch to buff out any air bubbles. Run your offset spatula or scraper around the cake a couple of times for the best results.
• Flat cakes stack up best. If your cakes are domed, slice off the tops. These scraps are "bonus" treats for you, the hard-working baker!
• Once you've added your filling and stacked the layers, press a few plastic straws or cake dowels down into your cake to stabilize it. Thick, bubble tea straws work really well.

🥚 Recipes with Leftover Egg Whites

This orange cake recipe will leave you with a lot of egg whites. Don't throw them out! Use them in an omelet, or try these sweet treats that use only egg whites:

• One dozen White Cupcakes, or wedding cake cupcakes, use 3 egg whites—and they freeze really well. Make a batch and freeze them for three months and you'll have dessert whenever you need it!
• Strawberry Pavlova uses 4 egg whites. It's an easy dessert despite the fact that it looks fancy! Just don't make it on a humid day. You can store the meringue shells in an airtight container in the pantry.
• Southern Coconut Cake takes 4 egg whites. Plus, you can freeze the cake layers for up to 3 months.
• Use the extras in this No-Bake S'mores Pie to create a ginormous cloud of meringue. Just make sure you don't get any egg yolk in the whites!

👩‍🍳 FAQs

📚 Related recipes

• This Lemon Layer Cake alternates fluffy layers of cake with sweet white chocolate filling and a light, citrus frosting—lemon lovers rejoice!!
• If you love chocolate and peanut butter, you need to try this Burnt Sugar Fudge Layer Cake ASAP. The decadent, rich layers are contrasted beautifully with light and airy peanut butter mousse. 10/10 recommend.
• Pig Pickin' Cake (sometimes called Sunshine Cake) is made with oranges and pineapple. Not only is it SUPER easy, but it's addictive.

🍽️ Serve with...

• Pulled Pork Tacos wth Mango Salsa
• Homemade Tater Tots
• Grapefruit Tequila Sour

📞 The last word

If you click on the number of servings in the recipe card you can adjust the measurements up or down for the exact number of servings you need. Don't forget that you can click on "add to collection" to save it to your own, private recipe box!

If you love this recipe please give it 5 stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

📖 Recipe

First published April 13, 2016. Last updated September 7, 2022 for editorial improvements.

What’s new? Check out my Restless Chipotle & Co. Store on Amazon where you'll find all kinds of nostalgic goodness!  Thanks so much for being a part of Restless Chipotle!